"[An] ingeniously constructed literary thriller."-- Minneapolis Star Tribune
"[An] elegant, hypnotic novel. . . . An elegy for lost--and perhaps only imagined--innocence." --The Washington Post
"Compelling. . . . Perhaps all novelists can be said to wrestle with morality; Mandel seems to wrestle with it at greater length and in greater depth than most. . . . First-rate fiction." --Dallas Morning News
"A novel noir that wears its influences proudly on the beige sleeve of its trench coat…. Delightful." --Paste
"Trumpets [Mandel's] talents: her charismatic verbal grace and acuity, the rich atmosphere she creates." --The Boston Globe
"Emily St. John Mandel is astonishing." --Emma Straub, author of The Vacationers
"[Mandel] is a stunningly beautiful writer whose complex, flawed, and well-drawn characters linger with you." --Sarah McCarry, Tor.com
"Fascinating." --Booklist
"Riveting. . . . Evocative, intriguing, and complex, this novel is as smooth as the underbelly of a deadly, furtive reptile." --Library Journal (starred review)
"A rewarding read." --Foreword magazine
"Result[s] in both sophistication and suspense." --Publishers Weekly
"[Mandel's] writing is pure elegance." --Patrick DeWitt, author of Sisters Brothers